Goulash…A winter’s Tale

The autumn has passed and the first heavy rains have arrived. The leaves start to fall and the temperatures begin to drop and the winter chill and shorter days set in. This is when my thoughts turn to slow braised, hearty meat stews and the absolute prince of stews is goulash.

Goulash Soup

Goulash Soup

I first became familiar with this down-to-earth slow braised comfort food during my early days working in the kitchens of Kibbutz Mishmar HaEmek in the Jezreel valley in central Israel.

The dish we prepared there was an Israeli version of the authentic working class goulash from Hungary brought to the early settlements in pre-state Israel by Jewish pioneers and later by Hungarian Jewish refugees after WW11. Goulash soon became one of the many adopted dishes that make up the mélange of Israeli cuisine today.

Today Goulash is found in Tel Aviv’s famous Yemenite quarter with a distinctly Middle Eastern flavour coming from the addition of Turmeric and Cumin (less paprika) while a more traditional Eastern European style dish is served in the local Jerusalem style restaurants as well as the chic brasseries surrounding Jerusalem’s Mahane Yehuda market.  For the average Israeli goulash is basically the generic term for a simple paprika based beef and potato soup or stew, perfect for the cold and rainy Mediterranean winter.
Called gulyás in Hungarian, Gulasch in German, guláš in Czech, and gulasz in Polish, Goulash is classically linked with Hungary or at least the cuisine of the Austro-Hungarian Empire and one could actually say “there is only one authentic goulash and this is the Hungarian one,”

A bit of Goulash History

Hungarian Gulyás is a thick, hearty working man’s dish that was popular among cattle herdsmen in Hungary. It was prepared in a cast-iron kettle hung above an open fire in the fields during the long dark winter herding times.5467172

Gulyás means Herdsman in Hungarian that where the dish’s name comes from.

Herdsmen have the best prime quality beef at hand and the rustic method of cooking fitted very well to their open air and always on the move life style.

This early working man’s rustic dish found its way to the more noble and urban table only towards the end of the 19th century.

During the Austro-Hungarian Habsburg dynasty’s rule in the late 1800s it became critical to protect the treasures of Hungarian culture; the language and the gastronomic delights as part of the movement to stress Hungary’s national identity and independence. Restaurants began to feature goulash on their menus and by the second half of the 20th century goulash had become the most typical of Hungarian dishes known to all.

A word about Paprika

Hot, sweet, smoked, plain, Hungarian, Spanish – all are paprika in one form or another a spice powder made from grinding a range of Capsicum annuum peppers.

Used for flavour, aroma and colour, paprika is one the most consumed and recognizable spices in the world and can be found in a multitude of spice mixes, rubs, marinades, stews, and as a garnish.

Depending on the type of pepper and how it is processed, the color can vary from bright red to brown and the flavour from mild to spicy.

Therefore, it is helpful to know the distinct qualities that each type of paprika can bring to a dish.

Most of the paprika sold in grocery stores is simply labelled “paprika.” Its origins may be Hungarian, Californian, or South American, and it is sometimes mixed with other chilies like cayenne. This paprika tends to be neither sweet nor hot and is a suitable garnish for things like devilled eggs or wherever you want some color.Hungarian paprika

 Paprika is the national spice of Hungary and is an essential part of the country’s most famous dish, goulash. Hungarian paprika is made from peppers that after harvesting are sorted, toasted, and blended to create different varieties. All Hungarian paprika has some degree of rich, sweet red pepper flavour, but they range in pungency and heat. The eight grades of Hungarian paprika are különleges (“special quality”; mild and most vibrant red),csípősmentes csemege (delicate and mild),csemege paprika (similar to the previous but more pungent), csípős csemege (even more pungent), édesnemes (“noble sweet”; slightly pungent and bright red), félédes (semi-sweet with medium pungency), rózsa (mildly pungent and pale red), and erős(hottest and light brown to orange). What is marketed in the West as Hungarian sweet paprika is usually the édesnemes variety.

Spanish paprika or pimentón

Spanish PaprikaAlthough usually less concentrated than Hungarian paprika, Spanish paprika can vary in taste from dulce(sweet and mild) to agridulce (bittersweet and medium hot) to picante (hot) depending on the type of peppers used (round or long), with or without the seeds, or how they are processed.

The peppers are harvested and dried over wood fires, creating smoked paprika or pimentón de La Vera. Smoked paprika is used in paella and dishes that need a deep, earthy flavour.

If you have a recipe that calls for paprika without specifying which kind, you can usually get by with using Hungarian sweet paprika. But also consider what type of color, sweetness, pungency, or heat you’d like to add and experiment with the wide world of paprika varieties!


So here are my two versions of Classical Hungarian Goulash and its hybrid Israeli/Yemenite off- shoot of Yemenite Beef Soup

A Classical Hungarian Goulash Recipe

Ingredients (for 5 hungry persons)

1 kg beef shin or shoulder or any tender part of the beef cut into 2×2 cm cubes

3 tablespoons good quality vegetable oil

2 medium onions, chopped

4 cloves of garlic, chopped

1-2 carrots, diced

1 parsnip, diced

1 bunch of celery leaves

200 gram medium tomatoes, peeled and chopped,

1 tablespoon tomato paste

3 fresh green peppers

4-5 medium potatoes cut into even chunks

1-2 tablespoons Hungarian paprika powder

1 teaspoon ground caraway seed

2 bay leaves

Freshly ground black pepper and salt according to taste

Homemade chicken stock

  • Heat up the oil in a heavy based pot and sauté the chopped onions until golden brown colour.
  • Sprinkle the onions with paprika powder. Cook until the oil separates and a nice paprika aroma is achieved.
  • Keep stirring to prevent the paprika from burning.
  • Add the beef cubes and sauté until browned.
  • Add the garlic,  ground caraway seeds,  salt and ground black pepper and bay leaf
  • Pour stock (or water) enough to cover the content of the pan and let it simmer on low heat for just about 1 hour. It can take longer depending on the type and quality of the beef.
  • Add the diced carrots, parsnip and the potatoes, the celery leaf and some more salt if necessary Add water or stock if needed.
  • When the vegetables and the meat are almost done add the tomato cubes and the sliced green peppers. Let it cook on low heat for another few minutes. You can remove the lid of the pan if you want the soup to thicken.
  • Serve with fresh egg noodles or Spaetzle

Yemenite Beef Soup4014220128


4 to 6 main-course servings

3-4 table spoons olive oil

2 tablespoons ground cumin (preferably fresh ground)
2 teaspoons turmeric

1 teaspoon sweet paprika
¼ teaspoon ground black pepper
1.5 kg meaty beef shank with bone
1 large onion chopped
2 ripe, medium tomatoes, or 4 plum tomatoes peeled and chopped
Chicken stock or water
4 to 6 fairly small boiling potatoes, peeled


  • Mix together the cumin, turmeric, and black pepper
  • Heat the oil in a large heavy casserole over low heat.
  • Add the beef shanks and brown in the oil
  • Sprinkle with salt and spice mixture and cook over low heat about 7 minutes, turning pieces occasionally so they are well coated with spices.
  • Add in the onion and tomato to casserole pot.
  • Add hot water or stock to cover and continue to cook until meat us tender.
  • Add potatoes and add more liquid if necessary so they are covered.
  • Bring to a boil, and then skim foam from surface.
  • Cover and cook over low heat until soup is well flavored.
  • Skim excess fat. Taste and adjust seasoning. Serve hot, in shallow bowls.


2 thoughts on “Goulash…A winter’s Tale

  1. Thank you for the lesson on paprika. Very good to understand the choices and differences. Is number 8 on frozen beef acceptable to buy for goulash here in Israel? It is less expensive will it tenderize in a slow cooker?


    • Hi Miryam,
      Glad you like the post. Beef No 8 is shin / shank. This is cut is perfect for traditional goulasch. One thing be careful not to not burn the paprika as it becomes bitter. Try to buy a fresh sweet paprika with oil…Gary


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s